Zugzwang · For club players · 19 min read
Zugzwang in Chess: Lasker's Middlegame Squeeze v Steinitz, 1896
The game where a chess magazine wrote that White had died of zugzwang, with queens and equal material on the board. Stockfish 19 shows Steinitz did not lose at move 34 but five moves earlier.
- threat
- target
- key square
- Mating squares
- pawn chain or line of force
In short
- Zugzwang means the player to move would be better off passing, because every legal move makes the position worse.
- In game 3 of the 1896 world title match Lasker built a bind with queen, rook and bishop against the white king, and after 34...Rg8 every White move lost, with material level and the queens on.
- Stockfish 19 shows the game was not decided by the famous final position: Steinitz was close to level after 28...h5 and lost with 29.g5, which froze the kingside, then spent the spare a-pawn moves with 33.a4.
- The lesson: tie each enemy piece to a duty, keep your own spare moves, and when the opponent runs out, hand over the move with a waiting manoeuvre.
How we know what we say
- Verified From the record: Stockfish's numbers, the players' own notes or interviews, or a cited source.
- Inferred Read from the moves and the position: a reasoned reconstruction, not the player's words.
- Speculative A guess about mood, intent or practical motives: plausible, not proven.
Part 1Moscow 1896: the first world champion's last chance
William Steinitz was the first official world champion, from 1886 until Emanuel Lasker took the title from Steinitz in 1894. Two years later the two met again in Moscow, from November 1896 to January 1897. Steinitz was 60; Lasker was 27. Lasker won the rematch decisively, ten wins to two with five draws. [5] Verified
| Steinitz | Lasker | |
|---|---|---|
| Born | 1836 | 1868 |
| World champion | 1886 to 1894 | 1894 to 1921 |
| Result of the 1896 to 1897 match | 2 wins, 5 draws | 10 wins, 5 draws |
Game 3, a Giuoco Piano, has a special place in the history of the strategy. When it ended after 34...Rg8, the Deutsche Schachzeitung reported the result in a single phrase, which Edward Winter cites in a history of the word zugzwang. [4] Verified
White has died of Zugzwang.
Most famous zugzwangs happen in endgames, with a few pawns and kings. This one happens with queens, rooks and bishops on the board and the material level, which is why it is worth studying. It also has a textual mystery: the sources disagree about White's 25th move and about how the game ended. Both are settled as far as they can be in the section on a different angle.
Part 2What is zugzwang in chess?
Zugzwang (German for "compulsion to move") is a position in which the side to move would rather pass, because every legal move makes the position worse. Chess does not allow a pass, so the player in zugzwang must damage the position with the move.
Zugzwang wins when two things are true. The defender's pieces are all tied to duties (guarding a square, blocking a line, defending a pawn), so none can move without dropping something. And the defender has run out of spare moves: harmless pawn or king moves that change nothing. The attacker needs the reverse: at least one spare move of their own, to hand the move back at the right moment.
- target
- White's duty
- Black's duty
- plan
- outpost
- White's duty
- Black's duty
The same kings and pawns. Without a spare move, White to play loses, and Stockfish gives Black a winning position. With the a-pawn's spare move, White wins. In zugzwang, the side with spare moves left wins.
Zugzwang rarely decides a middlegame, because with many pieces on the board someone usually has a harmless move left. Lasker's game shows what it takes: every White piece tied to a duty, the White pawns blocked, and Black with harmless moves to spare. The same idea runs through restriction and prophylaxis: take the opponent's useful moves away one by one.
Part 3How the Giuoco Piano opened the g-file
Steinitz chose the Italian Game with the sharp 4.c3 and 5.d4, then gave up the e-pawn with 7.Nc3 Nxe4 8.O-O. After 8...Bxc3 9.bxc3 d5 White played 10.Ba3, a gambit idea: the bishop on a3 stops Black from castling on the kingside, and after 10...dxc4 11.Re1 Be6 12.Rxe4 White wins back the piece but stays a pawn down.
1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 Nc6 3.Bc4 Bc5 4.c3 Nf6 5.d4 exd4 6.cxd4 Bb4+ 7.Nc3 Nxe4 8.O-O Bxc3 9.bxc3 d5 10.Ba3 dxc4 11.Re1 Be6 12.Rxe4 Qd5 13.Qe2 O-O-O 14.Ne5 Rhe8 15.Nxc6 Qxc6 −1.26Black clearly better
The opening to 15...Qxc6. White gives up a pawn for activity; Black castles on the queenside, out of the bishop's reach, and trades into a position a clean pawn up.
- threat
- idea not played
- key square
- target
Stockfish 19 rates 10.Ba3 a mistake that costs about two pawns of evaluation: Black castles long and keeps the extra pawn. Then, at move 18, Lasker gave the pawn back with 18...g5. After 19.Rxg5 Rxg5 20.Bxg5 Rg8 material is level, but the g-file is open and points at the white king. That open file is where the zugzwang will be born. Verified
Part 4Two plans from the same position
By move 24 both sides have chosen their plans. Lasker's king is safe on b7 behind the queenside pawns. Black's pieces line up against the white king on h2: the rook on the g-file, the bishop on d5 aiming down the long diagonal at g2, and the queen ready to join the bishop. White has a strong centre with pawns on c3, d4 and f4, but the white king has few defenders.
- plan
- White's king zone
- pawn chain or line of force
- plan
- key square
- The open e-file
The same position after 24...Rg6, seen from both sides. Stockfish gives Black about a pawn and a half. Black wants to pile up on g2; White wants space with f5 and activity on the e-file.
White's counterplay depends on the f-pawn and the pawn structure on the kingside. While White's g- and h-pawns can still move, White has spare moves and the bishop on g5 has support. Once those pawns are fixed, every white piece has a single job, and the spare moves start to run out. Inferred
Part 5The decisions that built the bind
Four decisions, two by each player, turned an ordinary middlegame into a zugzwang. Try each problem before you reveal the answer; the numbers are Stockfish 19's.
Critical moment 1 of 5 · Move 19, White to play
Lasker offers the g-pawn: take it, or keep the file closed?
- target
- key square
- The g-file
Black has just pushed the g-pawn to g5, where the rook on e5 and the bishop on c1 both attack it. Taking it wins back the gambit pawn, but it opens the g-file towards White's king. What should White do?
Think it through on the boardWeigh the candidates
| Move | Stockfish | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| 19.Qh5 19...g4 20.Qxh7 | −0.98Black clearly better | Stockfish's choice: the queen attacks h7 and leaves the g-file closed. Black stays better, by about a pawn. Verified |
| 19.Qe4 | −1.16Black clearly better | Offers a queen trade on e4, a calmer way to stop the attack. Black keeps an edge of more than a pawn. Verified |
| 19.f3 | −1.57Black clearly better | Gives the king the f2 square and keeps g2 covered, but is passive. Black is more than a pawn and a half better. Verified |
What Steinitz played
19.Rxg5−3.14Black winning
Steinitz took the pawn, 19.Rxg5 Rxg5 20.Bxg5 Rg8, so material became level and the extra pawn was gone.
Stockfish preferred 19.Qh5 (−1.02); the game move gave up about 2.1 pawns. Depth 19.
What it revealed
Material was the wrong thing to count. The trade opened the g-file for Black's rook and removed White's most active piece, the rook on e5.
What Stockfish adds Stockfish rates the capture about two pawns below 19.Qh5. It is the first of White's decisions that let the black pieces reach the king.
- Verified Stockfish 19 rates 19.Rxg5 about two pawns worse than 19.Qh5: the open g-file is worth far more than the pawn.
- Inferred 18...g5 is a pawn sacrifice to open a file. Lasker gives the extra pawn back to bring the rook to g8 against the king.
After 21.f4 Bd5 22.g3 Kb7 23.h3 Qb5 24.Kh2 Rg6 25.Qc2 f6 26.Bh4 Bc6 Black's grip was loose for a moment. Stockfish rates 26...Bc6 and then 28...h5 as the moves where Lasker gave back most of the advantage: after 28...h5 White is close to level. Even great players lose the thread, and both players here made big errors. Verified
Critical moment 2 of 5 · Move 28, Black to play
How should Black use the h-pawn?
- key square
- White's king zone
White's pawns stand on f4, g4 and h3 and the bishop on h4 eyes f6. Black would like to open lines against the white king and take squares from it. Which pawn move, or which piece move, serves that best?
Think it through on the boardWeigh the candidates
| Move | Stockfish | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| 28...f5 29.Kg3 Re6 | −0.94Black clearly better | Hits g4 at once and opens the e-file for the rook. Black keeps about a pawn's edge. Verified |
| 28...Rh6 | −1.35Black clearly better | Stockfish's choice: the rook goes behind the h-pawn first, ready for h5 later. Black stays more than a pawn better. Verified |
| 28...Qd6 | −0.92Black clearly better | Hits f4 with the queen. Playable, and Black keeps about a pawn's edge. Verified |
What Lasker played
28...h50.00about equal
Lasker played 28...h5, attacking g4 with the pawn and inviting White to push past it with g4-g5.
Stockfish preferred 28...Rh6 (−1.40); the game move gave up about 1.4 pawns. Depth 25.
What it revealed
The move gave White a chance: Stockfish says White can now reach a level game. But it set a trap, because pushing g4-g5 would fix the white kingside pawns and hand the h-pawn the road to h4, where it takes g3 from the white king.
- Verified Stockfish 19 rates 28...h5 more than a pawn below its choice, 28...Rh6, and after the game move the evaluation is level.
- Speculative Lasker may have judged that the practical chances were worth more than the engine's number: the move asked Steinitz to choose between pawn moves, and one of them was a serious mistake.
Critical moment 3 of 5 · Move 29, White to play
The pawn on g4 is attacked: push, defend or take?
- target
- key square
Black's h-pawn hits g4. White can push a pawn past it, keep the tension, or move the king. Which choice keeps White's spare moves and leaves the bishop free?
Think it through on the boardWeigh the candidates
| Move | Stockfish | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| 29.f5 29...Rg8 30.Kg3 | −0.08about equal | Stockfish's choice: the pawn takes f5 from Black, blunts the rook on g6, and the game is about level. Verified |
| 29.Kg3 | −4.31Black completely winning | Defends g4 with the king but stands on the g-file in front of the rook. Black wins about four pawns of evaluation. Verified |
| 29.Rg1 | −4.27Black completely winning | Defends g4 with the rook but gives up the e-file and puts the rook opposite Black's rook on the g-file. Black is more than four pawns better. Verified |
What Steinitz played
29.g5−4.56Black completely winning
Steinitz played 29.g5. After 29...fxg5 30.Bxg5 h4 the black pawn on h4 fixes the pawn on h3, takes g3 from the white king, and the bishop on g5 is now stuck blocking the g-file.
Stockfish preferred 29.f5 (0.00); the game move gave up about 4.6 pawns. Depth 24.
What it revealed
This is the move that lost the game. White gave up the last pawn moves on the kingside: the h-pawn can never move again and the g-pawn is gone. From here every white piece has a duty and only the a- and f-pawns have free moves.
What Stockfish adds 29.g5 throws away about four and a half pawns of evaluation: Stockfish gives about level after 29.f5 and a winning position for Black after the game move. The zugzwang at move 34 starts here.
- Verified Stockfish 19 rates 29.g5 about four and a half pawns worse than 29.f5, the largest swing of the game.
- Inferred The black pawn on h4 is the key to the final zugzwang: it takes g3 from the king, so a black queen or rook check on the g-file or the long diagonal has no escape square.
- target
- weakness
- key square
- No flight squares
After 31.Rf1 Rg8 32.Qd2 the duties are in place. The queen on d2 guards the bishop on g5 and the g2 square; the rook on f1 guards f4 and the first rank. Lasker now played 32...a5, a waiting move that asks White to find a useful move. Stockfish prefers 32...Re8 at once, but both win for Black.
Critical moment 4 of 5 · Move 33, White to play
White has two spare a-pawn moves: how many to spend?
- key square
- Tied to a duty
Every white piece is tied down. White's only free moves are pawn moves: the a-pawn can step once or twice, and the f-pawn can advance. What should White do with them?
Think it through on the boardWeigh the candidates
| Move | Stockfish | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| 33.Qf2 33...Qf5 | −6.36Black completely winning | Stockfish's choice: the queen moves while it still can and keeps both a-pawn moves in reserve. Black is still winning, by about six pawns. Verified |
| 33.a3 | −8.81Black completely winning | Spends one a-pawn move and keeps a3-a4 for later. Stockfish rates it no better than the game move: once the queen stays on d2, Black wins either way. Verified |
What Steinitz played
33.a4−8.97Black completely winning
Steinitz played 33.a4, the double step, using both a-pawn moves at once.
Stockfish preferred 33.Qf2 (−6.11); the game move gave up about 2.9 pawns. Depth 20.
What it revealed
White now had a single free pawn move left, f4-f5. Black needed only to waste one move with the rook to hand the move back.
What Stockfish adds The position is lost whatever White plays, but 33.a4 shortens the fight: it leaves White one spare move, and Black has two rook moves to spend it.
- Verified Stockfish 19 rates 33.a4 between two and three pawns worse than 33.Qf2, the move that uses the queen while it is still free and keeps the pawn moves in reserve.
- Inferred With the a-pawn blocked on a4 and the c- and d-pawns blocked, the f-pawn is White's last pawn that can move.
Part 6The turning point: 34...Rg8 hands White the move
After 33...Re8 White had no waiting move except 34.f5, Stockfish's choice too. Now Black played the move that gives this game its name.
Critical moment 5 of 5 · Move 34, Black to play
Black to play: attack, or wait?
- target
- Mating squares
Black's rook has just left the g-file for e8, and White used the last pawn move to get f5 in. Black can check, attack the f-pawn, or play a quiet move. Which move puts White in zugzwang?
Think it through on the boardWeigh the candidates
| Move | Stockfish | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| 34...Qd6+ | −7.88Black completely winning | A check that drives the bishop to f4 and gives White new squares. Black is still winning, but by less. Verified |
| 34...Re4 | −6.16Black completely winning | Activates the rook on the fourth rank and lets White's queen breathe. Still winning for Black, by a smaller margin. Verified |
| 34...Qe4 | −5.38Black completely winning | Centralises the queen but lets White push d4-d5 to block the long diagonal. Black keeps an edge of about five pawns. Verified |
What Lasker played
34...Rg8−9.74Black completely winning
Lasker played 34...Rg8, returning the rook to the g-file. The rook went e8 and back to g8 while White pushed f4-f5: Black had used two moves to lose one, and now it was White's move in the same bind.
Stockfish's first choice too. Depth 36.
What it revealed
Most sources say Steinitz resigned here. Stockfish confirms the zugzwang: White has 31 legal moves, 22 of them allow a forced mate, and the best of the rest still leaves Black almost ten pawns ahead.
- Verified Stockfish 19 rates 34...Rg8 Black's best move, ahead of the checks and the attacks on f5.
- Verified Edward Winter cites the Deutsche Schachzeitung of December 1896: after 34...Rg8, White had died of zugzwang.[4]
- Verified Tim Harding reports that most sources end the game here with Steinitz's resignation.[3]
Look at the hero diagram again: five white pieces, five duties. The queen guards g5 and g2; if it leaves, Rxg5 or Qg2 mate. The rook guards f5 and h1; if it leaves, Qxf5 or Qh1 mate. If the bishop moves, Rg2+ wins. Kg1 runs into Qh1+, and f6 drops the bishop to Rxg5. Stockfish confirms each of these refutations. Verified
33.a4 Re8 34.f5 Rg8 −9.74Black completely winning
The tempo loss in four moves: the a-pawn double step, the rook to e8, the f-pawn's last step, the rook back to g8. The rook took two moves to change nothing; White's pawns could not do the same. Inferred
Part 7What Steinitz could have done
By move 31 the position was lost, so the defence had to come earlier. Stockfish points to two decisions. The first was 19.Qh5 instead of taking on g5, keeping the g-file closed. The second, and the bigger one, was 29.f5, keeping the kingside pawns flexible. Verified
- plan
- Squares f5 takes
- pawn chain or line of force
29.f5 Rg8 30.Kg3 Qf7 31.Re6 Bd5 −0.17about equal
Stockfish's defence at move 29: the f-pawn advances, the king holds g4, and the rook goes to e6. The game is about level, against a decisive advantage for Black after 29.g5. Verified
The defender's rule against a coming zugzwang is to keep spare moves and keep pieces flexible. A pawn that can still move is a reserve of tempo; a pawn that is fixed is a lost reserve. 29.g5 fixed the h-pawn, 33.a4 used two a-pawn moves at once, and 34.f5 was the last free pawn move. Each step removed a reserve White would need. Inferred
Part 8A different angle: the zugzwang came five moves earlier
| Move | What happened | Stockfish after the move |
|---|---|---|
| 10.Ba3 | Gambit idea; 10.Bd3 kept the balance | Black more than two pawns better |
| 19.Rxg5 | Material level, but the g-file opens | Black about three pawns better |
| 28...h5 | Black gives back most of the edge | close to level |
| 29.g5 | The kingside freezes; 29.f5 held | Black about four and a half pawns better |
| 33.a4 | Two spare moves spent at once | Black about nine pawns better |
| 34...Rg8 | Zugzwang | Black almost ten pawns better |
Is the final position a true zugzwang, or is White simply lost? The test is to let White pass. With Black to move in the same position, Stockfish's best moves are quiet king and rook moves that hand the move straight back. Black has no direct way to break in. Black wins because White has to move. Verified
- key square
- Black's spare moves
The score itself carries two puzzles. Tim Harding found that the primary sources disagree about White's 25th move: some give 25.Qc2, others 25.Qf2. The two versions reach the same position after 32.Qd2, so the zugzwang is the same in both. This article follows the 25.Qc2 version, as Harding and the PGN Mentor database do. [3] Verified
Our impression is that 25 Qc2 is a more useful move than Qf2 and so more likely to be correct.
The second puzzle is the ending. Some databases add 35.Re1 Qxf5 36.Re5 Qf3 37.d5 Qg3+ 38.Kh1 Qxe5 39.dxc6+ Kxc6, and the PGN Mentor file used to check this score has those moves. Harding reports that most sources end the game at 34...Rg8 and that no one knows where the extra moves came from, so this article ends the game there. The extra moves start with 35.Re1, one of the few White moves that does not allow a quick mate, and Black wins anyway. [3][2] Verified
Part 9How to use zugzwang in your own games
The recipe
- Give every enemy piece a dutyCreate threats the opponent's pieces must answer: a battery against a square near the king, a pawn that needs defending, a file that must stay blocked. In the game the queen and bishop aimed at g2 and h1 and the rook at g5.
- Fix the enemy pawnsPawns are the main source of spare moves. Block them with your own pawns (h4 against h3, a5 against a4, c4 against c3) so they cannot move.
- Take the king's flight squaresA pawn on h4 took g3. When the king has no square, checks become mates, and every piece that guards the king becomes another duty.
- Count spare moves, yours and theirsBefore the last step, count the harmless moves each side has. You need at least one more than the opponent.
- Lose a tempo to hand over the moveIf it is your move in the critical position, waste one: a rook that goes away and comes back (Rg8-e8-g8), a king that walks a triangle, a pawn move kept in reserve.
Zugzwang is most common in king and pawn endings, where the opposition is the same idea in its simplest form: the king that has to step aside loses. Practise those positions first; the middlegame version is the same counting with more pieces.
- Which enemy piece cannot move without losing something?
- Which enemy pawns can still move, and can I block them?
- Does the enemy king have a flight square I can take?
- How many spare moves do I have, and how many does the opponent have?
- If it is my move in the key position, how do I lose a tempo?
Your turnPractise it
Set each position up, decide your plan before you look, then play it out against Stockfish to see whether it holds.
White to play. Each king guards its own pawn. How does White win?
Hint
You do not want to move your king. Is there another piece that can move?
A good answer
Play a3 or a4. The pawn move changes nothing, but now Black must move the king and give up e5, and Stockfish finds a win for White. A king move instead, such as Kg4, lets Black take e4 and draw.
White to play. Can White win this king and pawn ending?
Hint
Try e7+ and see where the black king goes; then try the king moves.
A good answer
No, it is a draw. After e7+ Ke8 Ke6 Black is stalemated, and every king move lets the black king keep the opposition in front of the pawn. With Black to move it would be a win for White: this is a mutual zugzwang.
White to play, move 29. Black's h-pawn attacks g4. Find the move that keeps the game level.
Hint
Push a pawn, but not the one that will freeze your kingside.
A good answer
29.f5, Stockfish's choice: the pawn blunts the rook on g6, keeps g4 and h3 flexible, and the game is about level. The game's 29.g5 left Black winning.
White to play, move 34, after 33...Re8. White's pieces are all tied down. Which move does Stockfish choose, and why is it the last of its kind?
Hint
Look at the only pawn that can still move.
A good answer
34.f5, Stockfish's choice. It is the last spare move; after 34...Rg8 White has none left and is in zugzwang.
Part 10What to take away
- Zugzwang means every move hurts, so the side to move loses.
- It can happen with queens on when every piece has a duty and the pawns are blocked.
- Spare moves are a resource: count them like material and do not spend them early.
- Fixing your own pawns can be fatal: 29.g5 lost the game five moves before the zugzwang.
- Lose a tempo to hand over the move: a rook out and back, a king triangle, a reserve pawn move.
Questions readers ask
What is zugzwang in chess?
Zugzwang is a position in which the side to move would be better off passing, because every legal move makes the position worse. Since passing is not allowed, the player has to weaken the position. The word is German for "compulsion to move".
Can zugzwang happen in the middlegame?
Yes, but rarely, because with many pieces someone usually has a harmless move. Steinitz v Lasker, Moscow 1896, is a famous case: queens, rooks and bishops were on the board and material was level, but every White piece was tied to a duty and the White pawns were blocked.
What is the most famous zugzwang game?
The best known is Sämisch v Nimzowitsch, Copenhagen 1923, often called the Immortal Zugzwang Game. Steinitz v Lasker, game 3 of the 1896 world championship match, is an earlier example: a German chess magazine reported that White had died of zugzwang.
How do you lose a tempo in chess?
You make moves that bring a piece back to the same position: a rook that goes away and returns (Lasker's Rg8-e8-g8), a king that walks a triangle while the enemy king can only go back and forth, or a pawn that can move one square or two. The idea is to reach the key position with the opponent to move.
What is the difference between zugzwang and stalemate?
In stalemate the side to move has no legal move and is not in check, and the game is drawn. In zugzwang the side to move has legal moves, but every one of them makes the position worse, and the game goes on.
Sources and method
The game score was checked against two independent sources. Every position, line and candidate in this article was replayed for legality, and every engine number was produced by Stockfish 19 WASM Multithreaded for this article (depth 18 to 37, deepest at the critical moments), not copied from elsewhere. What the players thought is reconstructed from the moves, their published notes and later analysis; it is labelled as verified, inferred or speculative, and nothing is presented as a quotation unless a source is cited for it.
- Tim Harding, Chess Mail: annotated PGN of all the Steinitz v Lasker games (game score, game 3 ends 34...Rg8 0-1)
- PGN Mentor: Emanuel Lasker games collection (game score; same moves to 34...Rg8, with the disputed extra moves)
- Tim Harding, Problem games between Steinitz and Lasker (the 25.Qc2 or 25.Qf2 question and the spurious ending)
- Edward Winter, Chess Notes: Zugzwang (the Deutsche Schachzeitung report of December 1896)
- Wikipedia: World Chess Championship 1896 to 1897 (dates, players, result)
Read next
Three pawns each, one passed a-pawn, eighty-two moves. Stockfish says the pawn never had to queen: it only had to make Black answer it with the wrong piece.
Building a Fortress in Chess: Giri Holds Sindarov, Candidates 2026An exchange down against the runaway leader, Giri built a fortress Sindarov could not break. The tablebase shows it was no passive wall: when White struck, only one move held.
Rook Behind the Passed Pawn: Alekhine v Capablanca 1927, CheckedThe last game of the 1927 world championship is the textbook rook ending. Stockfish 19 shows the rule decided it twice: once when Alekhine forgot it, once when it won the title.
Turn reading into skill
Strategy sticks when you use it. Practise real positions with Stockfish's verdict at once, or play the plans out from any diagram above.